|
Antigonish
Review # 141
| Lorri
Neilsen Glenn
Review
|
|

Cover Photograph: "Party Hats"
by
Glenn Priestley
|
|
Undone
by Sue Goyette.
(Brick Books, 2004, 155 pgs.)
Mortal Lessons
by Sue Sinclair.
(Brick Books, 2004, 89 pgs.)
Night Street Repairs
by A. F. Moritz.
(Anansi Books, 2004, 105 pgs.)
|
Poetry is
alchemy; it cracks open the quotidian and teaches us how to pay
attention. In the collections here, all by multi-award winning
poets, the reader's listening eye is rewarded with three different
poetics, each carrying its own astonishment and delight.
All readers come from somewhere. Rilke's often-quoted
comment on criticising works of art - "only love can grasp
and hold and fairly judge them" - describes where I stand.
As a seasoned teacher and always-apprenticing poet, I believe,
like Bachelard, that criticism can too often put the mind in a
"second position, destroying the primitivity of the imagination."
Reading to stay open, to imagine with another poet, teaches me,
invites me to wade in the river rather than watch or throw stones
from the shore.
This late-summer evening as I read Sue Goyette's
Undone again (and again), what comes to mind is the long
elastic sweep of a line over bright water: her work has the solitary
beauty of fly-fishing, yet it is rich with characters and a sense
of home. (Her long lines, by the way, are accommodated in the
book design - applause to Brick for the seemingly radical practice
of letting the work itself determine format). Goyette's elegant
cast and expansive reach explore loss and letting go: how do we
manage these, or do they manage us? In "New Year's Eve, 2001"
she reminds us that " … eventually even the night steps back,
/ turns into a pale, last star with all we're left of it slowly
burning out." "Patience" cuts to the essence:
Soon the hour of dry, folded towels, the hour of the empty
house will chime. Respirer. And in the silence, your
heart,
there are the hands of many memories working. Time
is the gasket, the thin slice of hope that fits between
the pieces. Here it works its quietest skill of undoing,
of slowly sorting what to keep
and who to let go (141)
The passion and grief in Goyette's poetry is
embodied, and can be knee-buckling: "There is a hunger in
us, / I think, for tragedy," she writes, and she cultivates
our awareness of it in kids' fingerprints, a discarded cardigan,
the loops of a knot tying and untying, spiders carried outside
in a young man's hands. Her words reach under our ribs, shake
us, the reverberations threatening our own undoing.
Imagine waking up and hearing crying,
that quiet sob of despair and rushing through
the house, then remembering. Looking out
the window to see only moonlight and concrete
(Jack Gilbert's Divorce, 21)
Undone is a long, deep breath of a book,
capacious, balancing optimism and the threat of despair. Goyette's
eye for what Bronwen Wallace called the stubborn particulars,
along with her heart-stopping metaphorical leaps, show us grief
as tender gestures of the everyday. This collection follows The
True Names of Birds, Goyette adding strength to strength.
Her wisdom here is in showing us how we keep on keeping on, our
arms, like her long lines, reaching into the depths, gathering,
reaching again.
Loneliness is evening's natural resource. Entire
lifetimes have been spent drilling offshore / of memory.
"Marry me," evening, down on its knee, begs dawn.
And dawn, with a little secret of its own, / agrees. ("A
week" 134)
Sue Sinclair's spare and brilliant poems are
lessons in economy: the fine elegance of ink line drawings or
the meditative clarity of contemplative photography. "At
night, the stars shine /like a cure that won't be discovered /
for years" ("Flatrock, January 1, 2002": 50). "We
are like smoke / rising into the world. Thin and quick / to lose
ourselves" ("Prayer I": 47). The spaces between
her philosophical observations are always apt, her moves deft
and accurate. But there is also abundance in the accuracy, like
a room quietly filling with light.
A spider spins a web simply to show
there is a perfect fit between all things.
The space between the porch and the rosebush
requires no adjustment. Between the rose
and its corollaries: earth, light. ("Witness III":
24)
Sinclair's evocations range from haiku masters
("heavy as peonies, / petal-thick rain", "Harbour
View": 36) to Dorothy Parker ("Water will drown you,
/ fire burn, air escape you", "Elements": 18).
The images are true and intimate, and the reverberations, as Bachelard
says of poetry, "touch our depths even before they stir the
surface."
We travel quietly, so as not
to draw attention to ourselves. The waves
slip like thread
in and out of the eye of a needle.
(Second View of Bell Island, October, 2001: 78)
Reading Sinclair has always been, for me, like
lying in an open field, watching the sky, and waiting. The practice
opens us to depths we couldn't otherwise have imagined, and when
we get up again, we often see the world around us with the precision
of a diamond-cutter.
Sinclair refers to her youth ("At twenty-nine,
already / I could spend all my time pondering what little / has
happened to me" "Suffering": 56), yet is aware
of "the shadow that comes / earlier these days." (83),
aware that "Dusk presses / at your back" (85). "Sometimes
the soul / wants to be all windows" (40), she writes, and
in her case, it is. Her philosophical observations are startling
and transcendent; her gaze, although measured, is expansive. This
poetry is all windows: so clear and sharp at times that language
disappears. This is Sinclair's follow-up collection to the award-winning
Secrets of Weather and Hope; and, like Sue Goyette's work,
can leave me speechless, marvelling.
God's lesson - his absence, that's
what we feel now. Religious vertigo,
dizziness that is the same
as being empty,
that is not the same as doubt
or belief.
("The Twelve Days of Christmas": 67)
A.F. Moritz's Night Street Repairs is
his sixteenth collection of poetry. His landscape is the world
- historical, cultural, classical; his gaze sweeps from Astrakhan
to Mexico City, from the Bible to Don Delillo. P.K. Page's cover
comment that Moritz is "a poet of high seriousness - rare
in this quick and confessional age" gives me pause. Aren't
most poets confessors, and serious? Yet it is true that Moritz
has a panoptical gaze, intense, compassionate, and scholarly in
the best sense (that is to say, the work is free from that insular
high-fiving scholars can indulge in).
"To see the day" is the blues, walking.
The weaving of city rhythms, the material and the interstices,
is fluid, touching dark and light, and somehow manages - how does
he do it? - to sing down the whole world.
Marvellous sea of
day,
producer
dandler of night, suspense of every horror and every pleasure,
all
equal, the things unjoined
floated in me, I joined them because I wanted to and nothing
avoids my alms.
"North American Song" shows us his
trenchant wit:
I have a mild case of everything.
I starve a little but not like they do in Ethiopia.
Life is empty for me but not like it is in Sweden.
I find I take longer with Moritz's work than
others', but the effort is worth it. Two sections in this book
("The End of the Age" and "Hymns") pull me
in for their particular critique of modernity and their elegiac
meditations on the universe itself. "Five Hundred Cities"
haunts me and "On a Sentence About the Ancient
Maya" provides one of the best contemporary commentaries
I have read:
Someone had to design,
before the stamping, each groove in your steering wheel,
the equally elegant radio dial, and the squeal
of the radio singer. We alone have imagined art
so powerful imagination can't get out.
"Clear Stream" might describe Moritz's
own work and its effect.
The water's clearness
offers the eyes the profound depths of fable.
And quick fishes,
lightning flashes, dream themselves and disappear.
We are left, near the end, with the moon and
its "dumb fellowship," a "rocky / satellite where
people have walked and thrown away / their garbage, making the
same use of it / as they do of earth." A refreshing take
on poets' perennial topic, "To the Moon" addresses the
rock as a sign
so like us
even when brightest you darken and hide
whatever's deepest in you, and endure this failure
Moritz's antennae is wide-reaching, and strong:
a semiotic magician, he is masterful in his ability to collapse
time and dreams in slender lines.
|